Throughout the years, Exeter Musical Society and its cast have enjoyed much success with the regional Rosebowl awards. We have received the following nominations and awards:
| 2004 – Oklahoma! | Nominated: | Best Actress – Michelle Crook (Ado Annie) |
| 2005 – Copacabana | Nominated: | Best Actor – Dean Brierly Best Choreography – Wendy Moore (Née Jackson) |
| 2006 – Oliver! | Nominated: | Best Show Best lighting |
| Won: | Best Actress – Lyn Burgoyne (Nancy) | |
| 2009 – Hello, Dolly! | Nominated: | Best Supporting in a Musical – Martin Southard |
| 2011 – Jesus Christ Superstar | Nominated: | Stage Electrics Award for Technical Achievement |
| 2013 – Guys and Dolls | Nominated: | David Whitehead Award for Best Actor (Musical) – James Billington (Sky Masterson) |
| 2018 – Oliver! | Nominated: | T-Work Productions Award 2018 for Best Youth Actor in an Adult Production – Tom Robinson as ‘Oliver’ |
| Nominated: | Manor Printing Award 2018 for Best Publicity Material. |
We have also received the following NODA nominations and awards:
| 2013 – Footloose | Nominated: | Noda South-West Award for Best Musical Production |
| Nominated: | Noda South-West Award for Outstanding Choreography – Evelyn O’Malley | |
| 2014 – Me and My Girl | Won: | Noda District Achievement Award for District 5 |
| Nominated: | Noda South-West Award for Best Musical Production |
